Where to buy gay men’s underwear online: 10 stores compared
We checked prices, sizes, shipping and returns at nine underwear stores on 7 October 2026, plus our own, so you can find the right jock without the guesswork.
The best place to buy gay underwear depends on what you’re after: a statement jock from a brand everyone at the bar knows, a fit that goes past XL, fast delivery, or a price that lets you buy five. On 7 October 2026 we compared nine popular stores and our own on the things that matter: jockstrap and brief prices, sizes, shipping and returns.
Gays+ wrote this guide and sells underwear, so read it with that in mind. We’re in the tables with everyone else, held to the same checks, and every claim about another store comes from that store’s own pages, listed in the sources at the end.
One change worth knowing: Andrew Christian, one of the best-known gay underwear brands, closed in December 2025, and its website no longer sells anything, so it isn’t in our tables.
Jockstrap and brief prices compared
| Store | Jockstraps | Briefs | Sizes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gays+ | $14.99–$35 | $14.99–$17.99 | S–XL on most styles; some to 3XL |
| Nasty Pig | $21–$45 in fabric; $69 in leather | $29–$39 | S–XXL |
| TOOT | About $37–$42 | About $34–$47 (bikini cut) | S–XL; some to XXL |
| Jockmail | $19.95–$30 | $19.95–$30 | M–XXL |
| Pump! | $31–$36 (sale from $22.40) | $35–$41 (sale from $28) | S–XL |
| MeUndies | $26, or from $13 a pair in packs | $26 (clearance from $7.20) | S–4XL |
| Calvin Klein (US) | $32–$40 ($14.40–$28 in a sale) | $28–$49.50 | S–XL; some packs to 2XL |
| Addicted | €21–€54 (about $24–$63) | €27–€54, mostly €30 | XS–3XL; many styles to 5XL |
| ES Collection | €33–€60 (about $37–$67) | €36–€78 (about $40–$87) | XS–3XL |
| Amazon | Mostly $7.68–$9.99 for generic singles | Varies by seller | Varies by listing |
Shipping, returns and packaging compared
| Store | Free US shipping | Returns | Discreet packaging |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gays+ | Every order, no minimum | Unworn, in the original packaging, within 30 days | Yes: plain, no Gays+ branding |
| Nasty Pig | Over $75 (contiguous US) | No returns or exchanges on underwear or jocks; faulty items only | Not stated |
| TOOT | Over ¥15,000; otherwise ¥3,500 by DHL | Unopened and unworn; ask within 7 days | Not stated |
| Jockmail | Not stated | Unworn; get in touch within 10 days | Yes |
| Pump! | Over $130 | Unworn, tags and packaging intact, within 15 days; never thongs | Not stated |
| MeUndies | Over $75; always for members | Unworn and unwashed within 45 days; your first pair even if worn | No |
| Calvin Klein (US) | Over $75; $50 for members | Unworn with tags within 30 days; a $4.95 fee for non-members | Not stated |
| Addicted | Over €100, worldwide | Unworn, tagged, in the original packaging, within 14 days | Yes: a neutral box, declared as fashion |
| ES Collection | Over €100, worldwide | Unworn, tagged, in the original packaging, within 14 days | Yes: a neutral box, declared as fashion |
| Amazon | Over $35 on items shipped by Amazon, or with Prime | Usually 30 days, unused; varies by listing | Not stated |
Store by store
- Nasty Pig: a New York brand with a big range of jocks, from $21 fabric styles to a $69 leather one. Underwear and jockstraps can’t be returned or exchanged under any condition (it cites New York law), so check the size chart twice.
- TOOT: made in its own factory in Hyuga, Japan, with weekly limited drops that usually aren’t restocked. Prices are set in yen, so what you pay in dollars depends on the store’s own conversion, and return requests must come within 7 days.
- Jockmail: the budget pick among the brands, with jocks and briefs from $19.95, shipped in discreet packaging. There’s no size S, and its shipping page quotes 10 to 30 days to the US.
- Pump!: a Montreal brand made in Medellín, with sporty jocks and briefs, and prices that include duties and tariffs. Sizes stop at XL, and returns are tight: 15 days, unworn, tags on.
- MeUndies: not a gay brand, but it sells a $26 modal jockstrap, goes up to 4XL and offers 45-day returns. Its First Pair Promise refunds your very first pair even if you’ve worn it. It doesn’t offer discreet packaging.
- Calvin Klein: the big mainstream name, with a small jock range and sales like the one running when we checked. Its US site only ships within the US.
- Addicted and ES Collection: Barcelona sister brands run by the same company. Addicted is the cheaper of the two, with jocks from €21 and many styles up to 5XL; ES Collection is pricier, with push-up and enhancing cuts. Both ship in a neutral box declared as fashion clothing.
- Amazon: the cheapest jocks we found, mostly under $10, from a shifting mix of sellers. Quality and sizing vary a lot, so read the reviews and check who’s selling.
Where Gays+ fits
We’re a store for gay men, so jocks, briefs, thongs, harnesses and pride gear sit in one place, with jockstraps from $14.99 to $35. Standard shipping is free on every order with no minimum, parcels arrive in plain packaging, and unworn underwear in its original packaging can come back within 30 days, which is more than Nasty Pig or Pump! allow.
Where we’re weaker: delivery takes longer than from a US warehouse, usually 7 to 20 days to the US, and we don’t stock the big designer labels. If you need a jock by Saturday, or you’ve set your heart on a particular brand, buy from that brand.
How to choose
- Measure first. Sizes vary a lot between brands, and most stores won’t take worn underwear back. Our sizing guide shows how.
- Read the returns rule before you buy. Nasty Pig takes no underwear returns, Pump! gives you 15 days and MeUndies 45.
- Count the shipping. A $21 jock plus $8 shipping costs more than a $25 one that ships free.
- Need a bigger size? Addicted (to 5XL on many styles) and MeUndies (to 4XL) go furthest.
- Want it discreet? Addicted, ES Collection, Jockmail and Gays+ ship in plain packaging. MeUndies says it doesn’t.
- Not sure which style suits you? Our jockstrap guide and underwear styles guide explain the options.
Sources
- Out: Andrew Christian is shutting down (December 2025)
- Nasty Pig: jockstraps
- Nasty Pig: shipping policy
- Nasty Pig: returns and exchanges
- TOOT: FAQ
- TOOT: refund policy
- Jockmail: jockstraps
- Jockmail: shipping
- Jockmail: exchanges and refunds
- Pump!: jockstraps
- Pump!: FAQ
- Pump!: returns
- MeUndies: shipping
- MeUndies: returns
- MeUndies: gift wrapping and discreet packaging
- Calvin Klein: jock straps and thongs
- Calvin Klein: returns policy
- Addicted: shipping
- Addicted: exchanges and returns
- Addicted: discreet packaging
- ES Collection: shipping
- ES Collection: exchanges and returns
- Amazon: returns policy
Jockstraps
Good questions
Where can I buy jockstraps online?
Gay underwear brands such as Nasty Pig, TOOT, Pump!, Addicted, ES Collection and Jockmail sell them on their own sites, and so does Gays+. MeUndies, Calvin Klein and Amazon sell them too.
How much does a good jockstrap cost?
In October 2026, most fabric jockstraps from gay underwear brands cost $20 to $45, with leather and designer styles costing more. Generic jocks on Amazon are often under $10.
Can you return underwear you’ve worn?
Almost never. Most stores only take back unworn underwear with its tags or packaging, and Nasty Pig takes no underwear returns at all. MeUndies is the exception, for your very first pair.
Is Andrew Christian still open?
No. Andrew Christian closed in December 2025, and its website no longer sells underwear.